Hello there π
How are you? What have you been up to?
The past few days have been intense here.
One of my kids started school (in the Netherlands, where I live, kids start school on the day they turn 4), bringing a wave of emotions and earlier wake-up calls.
Currently at β οΈ 5:15 am β οΈ.
Meanwhile, Iβve been preparing new sessions for you on a challenging topic.
π£ Trauma π£
More specifically:
How traumatic experiences can influence our beliefs and behaviors toward money.
And how specific financial events can affect us as intensely as traumatic experiences.
Despite its profound effects on individuals and society, this subject is often overlooked, especially by behavioral finance and money mindset programs.
So, for our next sessions together, I worked with two INCREDIBLE professionals (yes, ALL CAPS).
I also set myself three goals:
Shed light on the intertwined relationship between trauma and money.
Help you identify if it is a matter you or someone you care about should address.
Provide insights from and connect you with outstanding practitioners in this field.
As always on Money Feelings, we'll do it with a sprinkle of three of my favorite ingredients: optimism, humor, and creativity.
Welcome to our new series on:
π£Β Trauma π£
Please stay; it will be βfun.β π
π£ But first, if someone forwarded you this email, Money Feelings is your weekly dose of financial self-care designed to:
Kiss your limiting money mindsets and behaviors goodbye.
Grow your financial wisdom in style: less jargon, more emotion.
Increase your financial well-being, one feeling at a time.
If you donβt want to miss one:
You can also make yourself visible by sponsoring the free monthly newsletter or offering discounts on your services/products to Money Feelings readers:
If you want more information about Money Feelings, follow this link.
You can also follow me on Substack or LinkedIn.
Trauma starts.
It starts with a big event that hits us like a ton of bricks.
Right away, we might feel shocked, numb, or totally lost. We might get super scared, have panic attacks, or feel like we're not even in our own bodiesβlike we're watching from outside. Our heart races, we sweat, shake, or can't catch our breath.
In the long run, we might deal with lots of stress, bipolar disorder, flashbacks, PTSD, trouble sleeping, nightmares, or headaches.
Trauma can bring on all of these and more.
It has the power to change our personalities.
And our bodies.
A traumatic experience can change our brainsβ structure and function.
It can change our immune systems.
It can even change our genes.
Interconnection with money.
Research shows that trauma can also affect the way we behave around money.
You might think, "Well, money's not as important as my mental or physical health.β
But here's the thingβ Our mental, physical, and financial health are all tied together.
Financial issues can majorly impact our mental, physical, and overall well-being.
They can amplify our emotional struggles, leading to things like depression, anxiety, or even stress-related illnesses like hypertension.
And sadly, many people who've experienced trauma end up facing ongoing financial challenges.
It's because trauma can:
Mess with our ability to earn money, and
Cause us to develop harmful money behaviors.
New money behaviors.
We know that various forms of trauma can significantly influence the development and functioning of neural pathways within the brain.
This means that trauma can alter the way we make decisions, including those related to financial matters.
And so many of our daily decisions revolve around money.
From grocery shopping to eating out, online purchases, subscription services, saving versus spending, budgeting, investing, choosing transportation options, home maintenance, selecting insurance coverage, charitable giving, and banking choices.
Imagine if your ability to make even the simplest, most instinctive, and rational financial choices was impaired.
Trauma also shapes our beliefs about ourselves.
It can plant limiting and harmful beliefs in our minds.
These beliefs often involve distorted and damaging messages that can shape our self-perceptions and lead to harmful money behaviors.
Trauma can make us believe we're unworthy or inadequate, leading to feelings of not deserving success or financial stability.
It can instill a fear of failure or rejection, manifesting as reluctance to pursue opportunities for financial growth or advancement.
It can create a sense of helplessness or powerlessness, leading to a passive approach to managing money or avoiding financial responsibilities.
It can result in internalized shame or guilt, causing us to engage in self-sabotaging behaviors like overspending or financial recklessness.
It can erode our trust in others, making it difficult to seek support or guidance with financial matters.
The politics of βtrauma.β
The other day, I mentioned to a friend that I was diving into the topic of "financial trauma."
He rolled his eyes.
He's a psychiatrist.
He's tired of hearing everyone throw around the word "trauma" for every little life hiccup they encounter.
Heβs tired of people misusing medical terminology.
I get it. The guy who recently liked our Instagram post from January 2015 is not actually a βpsycho.β
However, the field of mental health is constantly evolving, recognizing new situations where the term "trauma" applies.
Take climate change, for example.
Professionals are now considering it a source of trauma as people worry about future events and deal with climate-related disasters (check out this article: Climate changeβs hidden threat: grief and trauma).
Similarly, financial psychologists believe certain money-related experiences can be considered "traumatic."
Money causes trauma.
Abrupt financial loss.
Overwhelming debt.
Enduring poverty.
Inability to retire.
Economic hardship.
Medical expenses.
Scary experiences involving money can hurt our financial and psychological health.
They can arise from one event and a complex interplay of individual circumstances and economic, societal, and systemic factors.
They can leave lasting scars on the psyche that are often referred to as βfinancial traumaβ (sometimes βmoney traumaβ or βfinancial PTSDβ).
Alex Melkumian, a psychologist and the founder of the Financial Psychology Center in Los Angeles described it to the New York Times as βan intense and enduring emotional response to current or past financial distress.β
While not a mental health diagnosis, financial trauma can - like traumatic experiences - distort our beliefs and behaviors around money.
Impulsive purchasing, hoarding, totally avoiding our finances, extreme frugality, workaholism, excessive fear of losing everything, obsessing over money matters, difficulty setting healthy financial limits and boundaries in our relationships at home and workβ¦
These could all be signs of experiencing financial trauma.
I will leave you with this example given by Brad Klontz in his book βPsychology of Financial Planningβ:
βDuring the Great Depression, many people lost everything. They trusted banks with their money, and the banks lost their hard-earned life savings. For many people, the belief that arose out of that traumatic event was. βYou canβt trust banks with your money.β
In the time of the Great Depression, that was 100% true and accurate.
But as time went on, regulations were put in place to prevent such a catastrophic event from happening in the future.
This did very little to restore a generationβs faith in the banking system, so many people report finding hidden money all over their deceased grandparentβs property: coffee cans buried in the year, rolled-up bills in the freezer, money under the mattress, and so on.
Intense emotion can make money beliefs rigid and difficult to change - a mindset of βIβm never going to let that happen to me againβ, no matter what.
This is why some people who grew up in poverty never feel like they have enough to feel safe and secure. [β¦]
Ideally, [someone] will be flexible and open to change. But if they are having trouble overcoming these limiting beliefs about money, it might be time for them to consider seeing a psychological professional for help.β
In the past 5 minutes, weβve seen that:
Traumatic experiences can influence our beliefs and behaviors toward money.
Specific financial events can affect us as profoundly as traumatic experiences.
Weβll dig deeper into all this in the coming weeks.
But Iβm pretty sure « weΒ Β» all need a little break right now, says the girl who woke up at 5:15 am β οΈ.
Thank you for showing up, and well done for finishing this first week. π
Youβll receive three more emails on the topic of π£Β Trauma π£ this month.
[Today] π©βπ Discover β±οΈ 5 minutes β
[Week 2]Β π§ Β Deepen β±οΈΒ 6 minutes
[Week 3]Β πΒ Master β±οΈΒ 8 minutes
[Week 4] πͺΒ Reflect β±οΈΒ 4 minutes
But for now, take good care of yourself andβ¦
π Share the love
What did you think?
I hope you found some value for yourself or someone you know in the past 5 minutes together.
If you did, let me know by clicking on the π at the bottom of the newsletter.
It means a lot!
I research and write Money Feelings for you π«‘, so never hesitate to share your feedback, ideas or ask questions.
You can do it in the comment section below or via a direct message:
If this session is helpful to someone you know, please forward this email or click the share button below.
πΒ LikeΒ | π¬Β CommentΒ | Β πΒ Share
ππππ
Very interesting, thank you Pauline. I can't wait to read the other emails on this topic!